
It happened to be the work of a photographer Yasuhiro Ishimoto that crossed my mind when I tried to convey a message which will hopefully take my students' violin-making experience into the realm of art. One day, maybe...
Music, specially where it is a live tradition, is art. There were the times, before the rise of Romanticism, when music-instrument making was art too. It was a few weeks ago when Jun Seki, a student of mine, suddenly asked: how does one determine the position of the sound-holes? It was an unexpected question. However after reflecting a second I understood, that this was exactly the kind of questions I was hoping to hear since some time.
A few months ago I tried to convey the idea of proportional, geometrical yet personal approach to violin-making. It was not readily grasped by my students at that time so I decided to postpone this subject till later. Additionally, I was not sure whether this was due to the complexity of the problem or due to my shortcomings with the Japanese language... somehow I must admit it's not a very easy language for me.
At that moment my students would rather want to know precise measurements expressed in the modern decimal system: 195mm from there to here, 25mm from here to there etc. At last, when Jun asked me how one determines the position of the f-holes, I said, "all right, you know, it's 195mm..." And suddenly I felt, it did not make sense to him anymore. Indeed, it does not make sense to me either. Jun expected me to elaborate on the Pythagorean tradition which made profound influence on the music-instrument making at least until the first half of the 18th century.
I quickly explained the use of proportions in the violin design and drew a simple sketch according to the method I developed 10 years ago...
Once we had it done with the sketch, we turned to the talk about craft and art. There are two ways out there: one way is to follow the tradition and ask no questions; another way is to absorb the rules of the tradition and break them, thus bringing the craft to another level, maybe, art's level - innovating, rejuvenating, producing new forms of expression, challenging the established tradition both emotionally and intellectually.
Traditions. We value them. Traditions survive thanks to the rules and thanks to the conservatism of those who guard them. For some reason, ancient Egyptian art did not evolve for thousands of years and the same is true for many arts in the Orient. This is, generally, not the case with the Occidental art, but even there, an artist willing to absorb and break the rules for the sake of freedom and innovation usually suffers from attacks of those on guard. This sounds like a personal, artist's drama, however the loss of traditions may be regrettable too. Isn't this a question of balance and culture? Shouldn't there be a Middle Way?
At that point the photograph by Ishimoto, one of my favourtite artists, came to my mind.
The picture is nothing but a stretch of asphalt street. Despite the simplicity of the subject matter the tonal range of it is extraordinarily rich. In other words, it is photogenic, engaging both visually and intellectually. In fact, it is as engaging as one wants it be because there is nothing to look at - just a piece of asphalt road. However, if one looks at it carefully, one starts to notice small details: thin cuts in the road. Probably, roadworks. Something like, "Walk here, please". This might symbolize the rules of a tradition: "This are our values: obey!" In the corner of the picture one can notice a pair of small white kimono shoes. They are out of focus, however it strikes that the woman, a geisha? "Geisha" literally means "an artist". She does not walk by the pre-established path, the cuts in the road. She goes her own way. This suggest the dangers and the personal drama of an artist who breaks away from the rules set by the tradition. While an artist going her own way is guaranteed the break with the tradition, she is not guaranteed to find her own way.
It was just a fine silver-gelatin print. Like wordless music, or music-instruments, it may have different interpretations. Depends on the viewer's (or listener's) heart.